Tuesday's special-called off-cycle board meeting (workshop) will be held on October 1, 2019, starting at 5:30PM. This is an official meeting of the board. The public can attended (but you will have to keep quiet.
Based on the Agenda, the board ought to be done by midnight. See the Agenda on the District's website.
Click on EXPLORE;
then on School Board;
then on AGENDA;
then on the icon (looks like a calendar);
then on View the Agenda.
No votes will be taken by the board. There will be no public participation.
Look on the left sidebar for the work for this workshop (meeting). Under "New Business - No Action Requested" are listed 28 (count them - TWENTY-EIGHT!) Policies to be reviewed, discussed and edited). If there isn't too much wrangling and horse-trading, the board will be asked to approve these at its next meeting, which is October 15, 2019.
To read the Policy and see the proposed revisions, click on it. Then click on the .pdf link that appears.
For example, Policy IHCF Childcare Programs. Did you even know that Richland 2 provides childcare for ages 5-14 before and after school hours? At no cost to parents?
Do you wonder why some employee is probably getting paid $50,000/year to change "5-14" to "five through fourteen"? And you're still wondering why your property taxes for schools are so high?
Some deal was made by the previous superintendent with the South Carolina School Boards association to update all the Board Policies? Since when does Richland School District Two have to engage in such widespread nonsense.
I think it was at the September 24 that one of the trustees chided the board about the District's feeling like it must do whatever the SCSBA says. It doesn't!!!
A community or parents' watchdog group should be examining every policy and communicating with board members before policies are reviewed. Give them your input. Your children will be affected by what the board decides.
Show up to hear the discussion. The board may or may not record and publish the October 1 meeting.
Spread the word about this blog. Tell your friends and neighbors to see RICHLAND2.INFO
Comments invited.
Friday, September 27, 2019
Wednesday, September 25, 2019
Board Alters October Meetings
Community members, parents and others who are interested in the business of the Richland 2 School Board should be aware of changes in the Board's schedule for October 2019. A workshop has been added at the beginning of the month, and the dates of the two Regular Meetings have been changed from the second and fourth Tuesdays..
October 1, 2019 Board Workshop (open to the public*) (not on the Meeting Calendar)
October 15, 2019 First Regular Board Meeting of the Month
October 29, 2019 Second Regular Board Meeting of the Month
Check the District's website for the starting times. Workshops often start at 5:00PM or 5:30PM
The public portion of Regular Meetings usually starts at 6:30PM (after the Executive Session).
* There is no Public Participation segment at Special-Called workshops.
October 1, 2019 Board Workshop (open to the public*) (not on the Meeting Calendar)
October 15, 2019 First Regular Board Meeting of the Month
October 29, 2019 Second Regular Board Meeting of the Month
Check the District's website for the starting times. Workshops often start at 5:00PM or 5:30PM
The public portion of Regular Meetings usually starts at 6:30PM (after the Executive Session).
* There is no Public Participation segment at Special-Called workshops.
Board Needs Parliamentarian
The Richland 2 School Board could use a Parliamentarian and a decision to observe Robert's Rules of Order.
There were too many times during last night's board meeting that one member talked over another. "Kindness" was the word for the night, and kindness was not shown during the discussion of concealed carry on Richland 2 school grounds.
Early in the discussion Dr. Elkins-Johnson made a Motion to replace one word in Board Policy GBEB Staff Conduct. Rather than allowing a second to the motion, the Vice Chair invited a comment by the superintendent, and he passed. There followed extensive conversation and discussion, and then the Vice Chair cut off further discussion with her own motion and quickly insisted on a second, which was provided by Amelia McKie. The Vice Chair then insisted on a vote.
But there was already a motion on the floor, that by Dr. Elkins to replace the word "superintendent" with "Board" in the draft Board Policy. Dr. Elkin's motion was never seconded or discussed as part of her motion, and there was no vote on her motion.
After lengthy discussion the Vice Chair cut off questions and refused to allow Dr. Elkins to continue with comments and questions to staff, so that staff could re-work the Policy revision. The Vice Chair wanted to table further discussion, and she was corrected by James Shadd that the procedure is to postpone, not "table".
During other Board meetings a Parliamentarian would have observed and corrected board members who engaged in side conversations and who used electronic devices during a meeting.
In an official Open Session of a public body, which the Richland 2 Board is, everything said or written is public record. If two members engage in a side conversation, the public usually cannot hear what they say. If electronic devices are used for email, texting, instant messaging, etc., the public has no way of knowing what is being transmitted.
The Parliamentarian should probably not be one of the board members, because he or she will end up not being too popular among friends. It's a dirty job, but somebody has to do it. Or should.
There were too many times during last night's board meeting that one member talked over another. "Kindness" was the word for the night, and kindness was not shown during the discussion of concealed carry on Richland 2 school grounds.
Early in the discussion Dr. Elkins-Johnson made a Motion to replace one word in Board Policy GBEB Staff Conduct. Rather than allowing a second to the motion, the Vice Chair invited a comment by the superintendent, and he passed. There followed extensive conversation and discussion, and then the Vice Chair cut off further discussion with her own motion and quickly insisted on a second, which was provided by Amelia McKie. The Vice Chair then insisted on a vote.
But there was already a motion on the floor, that by Dr. Elkins to replace the word "superintendent" with "Board" in the draft Board Policy. Dr. Elkin's motion was never seconded or discussed as part of her motion, and there was no vote on her motion.
After lengthy discussion the Vice Chair cut off questions and refused to allow Dr. Elkins to continue with comments and questions to staff, so that staff could re-work the Policy revision. The Vice Chair wanted to table further discussion, and she was corrected by James Shadd that the procedure is to postpone, not "table".
During other Board meetings a Parliamentarian would have observed and corrected board members who engaged in side conversations and who used electronic devices during a meeting.
In an official Open Session of a public body, which the Richland 2 Board is, everything said or written is public record. If two members engage in a side conversation, the public usually cannot hear what they say. If electronic devices are used for email, texting, instant messaging, etc., the public has no way of knowing what is being transmitted.
The Parliamentarian should probably not be one of the board members, because he or she will end up not being too popular among friends. It's a dirty job, but somebody has to do it. Or should.
Concealed Carry and Richland 2
When I arrived for the Richland 2 board meeting, I had my remarks all prepared regarding the selection of a small, general-practice law firm that was selected as bond co-counsel for "purposes of achieving diversity in the legal team". After I arrived, though, a more-timely subject came up.
On the way into the meeting I stopped to inquire who the armed man was at a school board meeting last month. He had been walking around in the board room before the meeting and, as he walked away from me, the butt of his small semi-automatic pistol was visible, tucked in holster under his shirt. I learned that two Richland 2 employees are authorized to be armed on school grounds.
Board Policy GBEB Staff Conduct was on the agenda last night for its first reading. Because of the huge liability exposure to Richland 2 School District, I felt strongly that the authority to allow concealed carry on school grounds should rest with the Board, not with the superintendent. And I said so during the Public Participation portion of the meeting. My comments can be viewed on the YouTube recording for the September 24, 2019 meeting at 21:20 on the meeting timer.
The current Policy reads, in part,
"The following list, which is not exhaustive, includes actions that are considered misconduct while on duty or on or off district property, or at any time when the conduct would disrupt the educational environment or impair the employee’s ability to be effective: ...
● possessing weapons on district property (unless otherwise authorized by law)"
Administration was recommending approval of a change, so that this item would read:
"● possessing weapons on district property (unless otherwise authorized by law and the superintendent)" (emphasis in the original)
When the meeting arrived at Item 12.1 on the agenda, the Board came to life! Teresa Holmes was chairing the meeting in the absence of James Manning, and she voiced her opinion. Monica Elkins-Johnson added extensive comments and questions to the discussion and had many questions for the Richland 2 staff there. James Shadd had questions. Lindsay Agostini, Amelia McKie and Cheryl Caution-Parker stayed out of it.
Discussion was boisterous at times, with trustees talking over one another and interrupting. Incorrect information was stated, and then corrected. Be sure to watch the video. The starting point on the YouTube recording for the Board's discussion is at 56:147 on the meeting timer.
Do you feel it is the Board responsibility to control who carries a concealed firearm on Richland 2 school grounds? Please comment below.
On the way into the meeting I stopped to inquire who the armed man was at a school board meeting last month. He had been walking around in the board room before the meeting and, as he walked away from me, the butt of his small semi-automatic pistol was visible, tucked in holster under his shirt. I learned that two Richland 2 employees are authorized to be armed on school grounds.
Board Policy GBEB Staff Conduct was on the agenda last night for its first reading. Because of the huge liability exposure to Richland 2 School District, I felt strongly that the authority to allow concealed carry on school grounds should rest with the Board, not with the superintendent. And I said so during the Public Participation portion of the meeting. My comments can be viewed on the YouTube recording for the September 24, 2019 meeting at 21:20 on the meeting timer.
The current Policy reads, in part,
"The following list, which is not exhaustive, includes actions that are considered misconduct while on duty or on or off district property, or at any time when the conduct would disrupt the educational environment or impair the employee’s ability to be effective: ...
● possessing weapons on district property (unless otherwise authorized by law)"
Administration was recommending approval of a change, so that this item would read:
"● possessing weapons on district property (unless otherwise authorized by law and the superintendent)" (emphasis in the original)
When the meeting arrived at Item 12.1 on the agenda, the Board came to life! Teresa Holmes was chairing the meeting in the absence of James Manning, and she voiced her opinion. Monica Elkins-Johnson added extensive comments and questions to the discussion and had many questions for the Richland 2 staff there. James Shadd had questions. Lindsay Agostini, Amelia McKie and Cheryl Caution-Parker stayed out of it.
Discussion was boisterous at times, with trustees talking over one another and interrupting. Incorrect information was stated, and then corrected. Be sure to watch the video. The starting point on the YouTube recording for the Board's discussion is at 56:147 on the meeting timer.
Do you feel it is the Board responsibility to control who carries a concealed firearm on Richland 2 school grounds? Please comment below.
Sunday, September 22, 2019
May 1 and Red4Ed
Remember the May 1st teacher's "strike" and how it affected Richland 2 schools? Just last week I watched again the April 30 school board meeting on YouTube and heard the words of the school trustees. Pitiful...
Today I came across this article titled "The NEA’s radical agenda: coming to a school near you" You can read the article at https://www.nccivitas.org/2019/neas-radical-agenda-coming-school-near/
To whet your appetite, are you concerned about
1. a $15.00/hour minimum wage for all staff?
2. White Fragility?
3. Promoting Black Lives Matter?
4. Teaching Climate Change?
5. union-friendly teaching resources?
6. Ending Criminalization of Border Crossings
7. Lobbying for LGBTQ Curricula?
8. US Government Must Accept Responsibility for Creating Immigration Crisis?
There is considerable concern about the left-leaning nature of today's teachers and a suspicion that they are indoctrinating their students with their own beliefs, rather than teaching critical-thinking skills so that students learn to make up their own minds.
Read the platform of the National Education Association (NEA). If these point concern you, watch for them in your child's class, homework and comments.
It won't be enough to complain only to the teacher, because there is a department and an assistant principal and a principal and a superintendent and a school board.
If you look at the composition of the Richland 2 school board, you will easily detect the lean to the left. While there may be staff members who don't lean left, they know where the power is and whom they'd better keep happy.
Understand what is happening in schools. Decide what you want for your child.
Show up at school board meetings. Bring your friends and neighbors.
Register to speak during Public Participation segments. And speak! Get involved!
Today I came across this article titled "The NEA’s radical agenda: coming to a school near you" You can read the article at https://www.nccivitas.org/2019/neas-radical-agenda-coming-school-near/
To whet your appetite, are you concerned about
1. a $15.00/hour minimum wage for all staff?
2. White Fragility?
3. Promoting Black Lives Matter?
4. Teaching Climate Change?
5. union-friendly teaching resources?
6. Ending Criminalization of Border Crossings
7. Lobbying for LGBTQ Curricula?
8. US Government Must Accept Responsibility for Creating Immigration Crisis?
There is considerable concern about the left-leaning nature of today's teachers and a suspicion that they are indoctrinating their students with their own beliefs, rather than teaching critical-thinking skills so that students learn to make up their own minds.
Read the platform of the National Education Association (NEA). If these point concern you, watch for them in your child's class, homework and comments.
It won't be enough to complain only to the teacher, because there is a department and an assistant principal and a principal and a superintendent and a school board.
If you look at the composition of the Richland 2 school board, you will easily detect the lean to the left. While there may be staff members who don't lean left, they know where the power is and whom they'd better keep happy.
Understand what is happening in schools. Decide what you want for your child.
Show up at school board meetings. Bring your friends and neighbors.
Register to speak during Public Participation segments. And speak! Get involved!
Friday, September 20, 2019
District Actions - how transparent?
Recently, a small, black-owned, law firm was added as bond co-counsel for the Richland 2 School District.
How did it happen?
On January 22, 2019, the School Board passed a resolution involving bond matters. It appears to have relinquished absolute decision-making control over bond matters to the office of the superintendent, presently held by Baron Davis. The resolution is mentioned, but not described or attached, to the Minutes of the January 22, 2019 School Board Meeting.
The resolution is ten (10) pages long, including signatory pages. On the final page of wording, seven lines from the end, is the following wording:
"Burr Forman McNair is authorized to associate co-counsel at the direction of the Superintendent for purposes of achieving diversity in the legal team."
Were the trustees cross-eyed and delirious by the time they read all the way through the resolution that they would be expected to approve on January 22?
Jabber & Isaac P.A. (jilawfirm.com) is a small firm with two principals, both of whom are female and black. Well, there is diversity for you.
The Board of Trustees should demand answers about their selection. How did that sentence get into the resolution? Did the Board direct it? Or did the superintendent request it? Or did one board member request it?
I don't have any problem with Burr Forman McNair inviting an experienced lawyer or law firm to partner up on bond work, IF a partner is needed to handle the work load. It seems to me that Burr Forman McNair would seek a highly-qualified co-counsel. Bond work requires high expertise in a very specific field of law. When you inspect the website of Jabber & Isaac P.A., you should be asking yourself, "Where is their bond experience?"
As of today, their website lists the types of work they do. The list includes real estate; family and domestic law; estate planning and probate; business law; governmental relations; personal injury; workers' compensation; and Social Security Disability. There is no mention of municipal bond work or school bond work.
Did Burr Forman McNair select Jabber & Isaac P.A. and tell Supt. Davis that they like to pull in Jabber & Isaac as co-counsel?
Did Supt. Davis direct Burr Forman McNair to select Jabber & Isaac? If he did, why that specific form? Because the principals are women? or because they are black women?
Is there a potential conflict-of-interest between any Board Trustee and either principal at Jabber & Isaac for personal, professional or business reasons? Did the superintendent pick Jabber & Isaac on his own, or was there a "suggestion" from a board member?
On the School District website the profile of Amelia McKie includes "She is a founding partner of Nfusion, LLC, which provides governmental relations and communications/public relations services for municipal, state and private agencies. She advocates for various institutions of higher education throughout South Carolina."
The words that jump from the page are "governmental relations" and "services for municipal, state and private agencies."
Interestingly enough, the April 11, 2019 document for the sale of $26,000,000 sale of Bond Anticipation Notes lists Amelia McKie's occupation as "Community Volunteer". The document does not mention her work as a lobbyist or consultant or her position as School Board Trustee, for which she received IRS W-2 income.
Amelia McKie has been filing Lobbyist Reports since May 2009. The most recent report was filed January 28, 2019.
See ethics.sc.gov
On the homepage, click on the link for Public Reporting
Scroll down and click on Lobbying Activity
Under Individual Reports, click on Lobbyists
Enter McKie, then click Next
Click on McKie, Amelia B
Her own firm (Nfusion, LLC) is not there, but NextEra Energy, Inc. is. (if you wonder what that is, click here.)
How did it happen?
On January 22, 2019, the School Board passed a resolution involving bond matters. It appears to have relinquished absolute decision-making control over bond matters to the office of the superintendent, presently held by Baron Davis. The resolution is mentioned, but not described or attached, to the Minutes of the January 22, 2019 School Board Meeting.
The resolution is ten (10) pages long, including signatory pages. On the final page of wording, seven lines from the end, is the following wording:
"Burr Forman McNair is authorized to associate co-counsel at the direction of the Superintendent for purposes of achieving diversity in the legal team."
Were the trustees cross-eyed and delirious by the time they read all the way through the resolution that they would be expected to approve on January 22?
Jabber & Isaac P.A. (jilawfirm.com) is a small firm with two principals, both of whom are female and black. Well, there is diversity for you.
The Board of Trustees should demand answers about their selection. How did that sentence get into the resolution? Did the Board direct it? Or did the superintendent request it? Or did one board member request it?
I don't have any problem with Burr Forman McNair inviting an experienced lawyer or law firm to partner up on bond work, IF a partner is needed to handle the work load. It seems to me that Burr Forman McNair would seek a highly-qualified co-counsel. Bond work requires high expertise in a very specific field of law. When you inspect the website of Jabber & Isaac P.A., you should be asking yourself, "Where is their bond experience?"
As of today, their website lists the types of work they do. The list includes real estate; family and domestic law; estate planning and probate; business law; governmental relations; personal injury; workers' compensation; and Social Security Disability. There is no mention of municipal bond work or school bond work.
Did Burr Forman McNair select Jabber & Isaac P.A. and tell Supt. Davis that they like to pull in Jabber & Isaac as co-counsel?
Did Supt. Davis direct Burr Forman McNair to select Jabber & Isaac? If he did, why that specific form? Because the principals are women? or because they are black women?
Is there a potential conflict-of-interest between any Board Trustee and either principal at Jabber & Isaac for personal, professional or business reasons? Did the superintendent pick Jabber & Isaac on his own, or was there a "suggestion" from a board member?
On the School District website the profile of Amelia McKie includes "She is a founding partner of Nfusion, LLC, which provides governmental relations and communications/public relations services for municipal, state and private agencies. She advocates for various institutions of higher education throughout South Carolina."
The words that jump from the page are "governmental relations" and "services for municipal, state and private agencies."
Interestingly enough, the April 11, 2019 document for the sale of $26,000,000 sale of Bond Anticipation Notes lists Amelia McKie's occupation as "Community Volunteer". The document does not mention her work as a lobbyist or consultant or her position as School Board Trustee, for which she received IRS W-2 income.
Amelia McKie has been filing Lobbyist Reports since May 2009. The most recent report was filed January 28, 2019.
See ethics.sc.gov
On the homepage, click on the link for Public Reporting
Scroll down and click on Lobbying Activity
Under Individual Reports, click on Lobbyists
Enter McKie, then click Next
Click on McKie, Amelia B
Her own firm (Nfusion, LLC) is not there, but NextEra Energy, Inc. is. (if you wonder what that is, click here.)
Wednesday, September 18, 2019
Selection of small minority law firm explained
If you are short on time, the explanation is at the bottom of this article.
When I heard a second bond lawyer introduced at the September 10th school board meeting, I wondered what was up. And when I watched the re-run of the meeting on the school district's YouTube, I watched the face of Board Chair Manning carefully.
When Attorney Frannie Heizer, of Burr & Forman, was introduced, Mr. Manning nodded at her. Obviously, he recognized her name and her, because Burr & Forman created the documents for the April 11th sale of $26,000,000 in Bond Anticipation Notes. Recall that it was the two additional certifications to those documents that had resulted in the resignation of Lindsay Agostini from her position as Board Secretary.
When the superintendent introduced a second lawyer, Tameika Isaac Devine, I watched Manning's face carefully through several re-runs of the YouTube recording. He didn't nod; he didn't smile. He didn't seem to know who she was. (I immediately thought, "I'm never playing poker with James Manning!" (And this is a compliment.))
Looking back through Minutes of Board meetings, I came to the January 22, 2019 meeting, where I found one line that began to explain things. In Item 10.1 there was a Motion "To authorize the issuance and sale of general obligation bonds not exceeding $468,406,000 and to authorize the superintendent or his designee to determine matters relating to the bonds and notes as outlined in the resolution."
The Motion was made by Shadd, seconded by Elkins-Johnson. There were six Yes votes, zero No votes, and one Abstain (by Agostini).
Naturally, I wondered what was in the resolution which, conveniently, was not attached to the Minutes. So I requested a copy of the resolution.
The resolution is ten pages and has to be a $1,000 document by itself; maybe more. On the one hand, for a large bond-oriented law firm or section thereof, much of it is probably a boiler-plate document. It wasn't created from scratch for that sale. But it had to be careful read and edited, and I'll bet it is more like a $10,000 document; maybe a lot more.
Basically, it grants full authority to the (office of) superintendent for anything and everything pertaining to the $468MM bond issue that voters approved in November 2018.
And, when you read all the way to the end, in Section 21 there is one sentence that explains the addition of a small, Columbia law firm with no apparent experience in multi-million dollar bond work. That sentence reads, "Burr Forman McNair is authorized to associate co-counsel at the direction of the superintendent for purposes of achieving diversity in the legal team."
And that, folks, is a crock. Burr & Forman (the correct name since January) probably said, "What the hell?" But they will do what the superintendent tells them to do (and pays for them to do).
Look at the areas of practice of Jabber & Isaac, P.A. You'll find them listed on their website. You'll read "real estate; business law; Social Security disability; workers' compensation; automobile accidents and personal injury; family law; governmental relations."
Bond law is a full-time job, requiring expertise, study, knowledge, training. Why should Richland 2 pay a small "diverse" law firm to learn how to practice in the area of bond law?
How much money will Richland 2 School District waste because of 23 words tossed unnecessarily into the resolution?
When I heard a second bond lawyer introduced at the September 10th school board meeting, I wondered what was up. And when I watched the re-run of the meeting on the school district's YouTube, I watched the face of Board Chair Manning carefully.
When Attorney Frannie Heizer, of Burr & Forman, was introduced, Mr. Manning nodded at her. Obviously, he recognized her name and her, because Burr & Forman created the documents for the April 11th sale of $26,000,000 in Bond Anticipation Notes. Recall that it was the two additional certifications to those documents that had resulted in the resignation of Lindsay Agostini from her position as Board Secretary.
When the superintendent introduced a second lawyer, Tameika Isaac Devine, I watched Manning's face carefully through several re-runs of the YouTube recording. He didn't nod; he didn't smile. He didn't seem to know who she was. (I immediately thought, "I'm never playing poker with James Manning!" (And this is a compliment.))
Looking back through Minutes of Board meetings, I came to the January 22, 2019 meeting, where I found one line that began to explain things. In Item 10.1 there was a Motion "To authorize the issuance and sale of general obligation bonds not exceeding $468,406,000 and to authorize the superintendent or his designee to determine matters relating to the bonds and notes as outlined in the resolution."
The Motion was made by Shadd, seconded by Elkins-Johnson. There were six Yes votes, zero No votes, and one Abstain (by Agostini).
Naturally, I wondered what was in the resolution which, conveniently, was not attached to the Minutes. So I requested a copy of the resolution.
The resolution is ten pages and has to be a $1,000 document by itself; maybe more. On the one hand, for a large bond-oriented law firm or section thereof, much of it is probably a boiler-plate document. It wasn't created from scratch for that sale. But it had to be careful read and edited, and I'll bet it is more like a $10,000 document; maybe a lot more.
Basically, it grants full authority to the (office of) superintendent for anything and everything pertaining to the $468MM bond issue that voters approved in November 2018.
And, when you read all the way to the end, in Section 21 there is one sentence that explains the addition of a small, Columbia law firm with no apparent experience in multi-million dollar bond work. That sentence reads, "Burr Forman McNair is authorized to associate co-counsel at the direction of the superintendent for purposes of achieving diversity in the legal team."
And that, folks, is a crock. Burr & Forman (the correct name since January) probably said, "What the hell?" But they will do what the superintendent tells them to do (and pays for them to do).
Look at the areas of practice of Jabber & Isaac, P.A. You'll find them listed on their website. You'll read "real estate; business law; Social Security disability; workers' compensation; automobile accidents and personal injury; family law; governmental relations."
Bond law is a full-time job, requiring expertise, study, knowledge, training. Why should Richland 2 pay a small "diverse" law firm to learn how to practice in the area of bond law?
How much money will Richland 2 School District waste because of 23 words tossed unnecessarily into the resolution?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
-
Reporter Michael Smith of The Independent Voice of Blythewood & Fairfield County contacted me for a comment after the Richland 2 Scho...
-
What is the position of the Richland 2 School Board, when it comes to Federal enforcement against children of illegal aliens? Is the NEA (Na...
-
The following results of yesterday's Richland 2 school board election are being reported: Monica Elkins 24,889 Shell...
